Truth. Ever elusive, ever pursued. Truth is an object. In Genesis it is embodied in the forbidden fruit of the tree of knowledge of all (good and evil, a merism). Its pursuit by Eve and then Adam doomed Man to eviction and mortality. Control. Mastery of knowledge. The original temptation to be like God through knowing all is still with us. Was Eve's intention, and Adam's who joined in the feast, to simply know? Was it to be like God? Or was it to act on what she learned?
Science, in its purist form, is the pursuit of knowledge for knowledge's sake. To understand how the world works. To eat the forbidden fruit. I'm afraid our intrinsic flaw, our Original Sin, goes beyond curiosity. Possessing knowledge; owning knowledge progresses to controlling knowledge. Knowledge begets more knowledge. Eventually acting on knowledge is not far along this slippery slope of possession-to-action. It is not enough to "be", we must "act".
Technology, in its purist form, is the application of knowledge to achieve some other end--an action. To solve a problem. To dominate in war. To cure a patient. To make money. Which is worse: to emulate God by being (knowing what He knows) or action (killing or modifying His creations, creating new things)? In other words, which demonstrates the most hubris?
To act with over-confidence, to act with hubris seem to me the most problematic. To shoot and ask questions later. To lack respect of the complexity of the reactions to our actions. These, in my opinion, reflect the greater evil. We all know this on some level. We know that acting prematurely is a bad thing. "Prematurely" of what? Fullness of understanding--both in terms of the basis for action (is it Right?) and the ramifications of action (and inaction). To "act without thinking" is to demonstrate lack of knowledge and/or respect of knowledge. In other words, we should strive to act, if act we must, wisely.
Not acting can also be a sign of ignorance or wisdom. Both of these intellectual states seem preferable to not acting due to incomplete knowledge and simultaneously lacking interest in gaining more information to support inaction.
To me, Eve's (and Adams') flaw was the disrespect she showed to God, Knowledge itself. She harbored the delusion that it was even possible to Understand all. And this mortal flaw came to light through action. Not action with knowledge; action to obtain knowledge without concern of the consequences. It was the first hubristic act of humanity. After being thrust from the Garden we were condemned to act with incomplete knowledge, our access to the Tree of Knowledge being blocked forever.
Our "inherited" yearning to learn stays with us. As does the uncontrollable urge to act. As with Eve, yearning to learn has combined with action. Science has melded with technology. We don't seem to be able to marvel at knowing anymore and be content. There is always more. It isn't enough to understand what, when, why or how and stop. We must take this first step with an eye toward purpose. Why do we wish to know why? How will we apply the know-how? When will we apply our knowledge of the event? What will we make with what we have learned?
Action itself is not necessarily bad. If humanity applied deference, doubt and pause to its actions then perhaps I would not fear it. Instead we have a history of things like:
1. The Holocaust - deranged social Darwinism applied in a milieu of hate
2. Communism - hubris that the fabric of society was just another machine to construct, operate and maintain.
3. Nuclear fission - the most potent of the mixture of science with Man's weaknesses
4. Monetization of Medicine - the pharmaceutical and medical device industries whose natural profit motives govern their actions have corrupted medical science at all levels of knowledge dissemination
5. Global warming - technology's largest scale side-effect.
Knowledge and its conjoined twin, applied knowledge, have become inseparable. We cannot have one without the other. It is for that very reason that I wonder about the wisdom of knowing at all. Or at least jumping into gaining more knowledge without the realization that for every kernel of information harvested their is a loaf of bread destined to be made.
So when an issue like stem cell research pops into the queue of fields to be explored I cringe a bit. I become torn by the eagerness to understand and the certainty that the meme of applied technology (to treat human disease) will come along uninvited (by me). We cannot just know we have to do; even at the high expense and unknown sequelae that will come with something so fundamental, in the scientific sense, as stem cell research. I hope, probably in vain, that discovery can proceed slow enough to allow for wise application of knowledge.
Monday, March 9, 2009
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)